Friday, July 30, 2004

No feedback, no critique

On any list of writer's complaints you'll find "no feedback on rejections" near the top of the list.

Most writers understand why agents don't offer feedback, or anything more than a form letter on queries. They understand the time debit of personal responses.

Start talking about partials and fulls though, the attitude changes. I understand that. I do.

But, here's what I do instead: I read more fulls.

Writing personal responses, analyzing, taking notes, writing an email; all those things take time. I elect to invest that time in another way: reading a manuscript.

I understand a form rejection of a full is galling, but think of it this way: I asked for and read your manuscript because I didn't spend time critiquing the other guy's novel.

The only place I critique work is the Query Shark blog.


  1. That's rather comforting.

    But what about when an agent requests the full typescript, and five months later one has heard nothing? Is one to think that she's reading even more fulls than you do?

  2. Not that comforting to me, but I love your honesty. :-) Thanks!


Keep your comments succinct. Any comment that runs longer than 100 words is generally too long.

If you're commenting more than three times a day, it's too much.

Civility is enforced. Spelling/grammar mistakes may be pointed out ONLY in the blog post itself, not in any of the ensuing commenter's contributions.

If your comment doesn't show up, it's most likely that Blogger ate it. Try posting again using a GoogleID. (comment moderation is on only for older posts)